The Film Talk - The ongoing podcast conversation about movies with Jett Loe and Gareth HigginsAsk The Film TalkNashville Scene Best Film Podcast 2009

Clint Eastwood’s Moral Imagination and Why Glenn Beck Should Read More Speeches

October 30th, 2009by Gareth Higgins · Comments

invictus poster

It’s that time of year again – you know, when Clint Eastwood releases a trailer for a movie that looks fascinating and completely different from the last thing he did, and your triple reactions run something like this: 1: Hmmm, Clint’s got a movie coming out – didn’t we just see ‘Gran Torino’ five minutes ago?; 2: Hmmm, it’s got Morgan Freeman playing Nelson Mandela in it – how come no one ever thought of that before?; 3: Hmmm, it’s a movie about the 1995 Rugby World Cup - how come no one ever thought of that before?  Well, no one ever thought of making a gripping film out of the ancient ‘old racist bloke in Detroit has his heart melted by a Hmong family and saves the world through non-violent atonement metaphor before singing a jazz song over the early end credits’ plot either.  So I’m rather excited about ‘Invictus’ – biopics are always a risky proposition, but there’s an implication in the trailer that this one might do more than retread what we already know or think we know.

Mandela has rightly become an unimpeachable moral figure, but it’s par for the course to ignore what he actually stood for – our Mandela is more than a mascot, though our culture might prefer him that way; he actually has things to say.  Icons of moral authority who act toward the common good are often treated this way: I was astonished yesterday to see the digital wall montage that Glenn Beck uses to underline the gravity of what he’s saying – accompanied by the invocation ‘Speak Without Fear’, an image of Dr Martin Luther King, Jr appeared, leading into Beck denouncing (yet again) concerns about climate change, and announcing his willingness to go to prison for the right to eat steak.  We might imagine Dr King would agree that particular cause doesn’t exactly warrant a new letter from a Birmingham jail.

In fact, we might also imagine that a reading of Dr King’s actual thoughts about the actual world would surprise Glenn Beck and his audience.  In fact, and let me not be misunderstood: it’s kind of obscene for a man who recently imagined aloud his fantasy to poison Nancy Pelosi and joked about President Obama setting the people on fire to attempt to inveigle his way into the legacy of non-violence enacted by a man who, there can be little doubt, Beck would be denouncing if he were alive today.  But if his audience were being exposed to what he actually said about the world, I’d tune in every day.  Come to think of it, that’s not a bad idea – maybe we could organise a TFT-inspired campaign to encourage talk show hosts only to use images of moral leaders if they’re going to spend two minutes every show actually quoting what they actually said.  Beck could begin with some reference to Dr King’s ‘Giant Triplets of racism, extreme materialism and militarism’; maybe he could just agree to read a paragraph a day from his ‘Beyond Vietnam‘ speech…

Lest I get ahead of myself, let’s get back to the movies – I’m hopeful that the Eastwood/Freeman Mandela is more than a cliche, and resists the urge to laze in platitudes.  Clint’s last movie showed something about quiet authority, and portrayed a radical idea: that justice or peace sometimes costs its proponents a very great deal; it did this without barnstorming speeches or spelling it out; it gets better in the memory every time I think about it.  Eastwood’s Walt Kowalski in ‘Gran Torino’ felt like the culmination of every iconic character Clint has played – a man with no name/Dirty Harry all grown up and full of regret for past mistakes, who makes a choice to invert it all, and live beyond the narrow circle of selfishness.  Mandela made that choice a long time ago – who knows what Clint’s vision of a moment in his life might bring?  We might be about to see a film about an iconic figure that transcends the typical mistakes of making him unreachable to the rest of us; we might actually see a portrayal of Mandela that tells us something about leadership rather than merely represents him as a kind of political pop star.

Tell Others About This! These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Digg
  • Sphinn
  • del.icio.us
  • email
  • MisterWong
  • Reddit
  • Technorati
  • StumbleUpon
  • NewsVine
  • TwitThis
  • Facebook

Tags: Actors We Love · Directors · Drama · Gareth Higgins

  • Glenn Beck is a disgrace to the religious community. He claims to be Mormon, but if you actually study Mormonism, almost everything he spouts off is in direct contradiction to the principles of the faith. The same is true of a large portion of the evangelical right. Reason and logic seem to have no place in the religious community anymore. Healthy skepticism has been replaced by blind obedience to a book that can't even agree with itself on simple points of doctrine. Now, I believe pure religion can enlighten, provoke deep thought, enhance community, and neutralize societal evils and injustice, but what most people practice nowadays can hardly be considered pure religion.

    * * * * * * * * *

    Anyway, it's always risky to cast well-known actors in roles that require foreign accents. If Damon and Freeman can tackle that without too much distraction, then this film looks to be quite fascinating.
  • The irony (??, or is it homage?) in the Glenn Beck thing, sounds like something that Keith Olberman would call him on - and indeed, Keith would read some of a King speech to qualify just what you said. (I'll admit though, I've never watched or listened to anything Glenn Beck has had to say - other than clips played on say The Daily Show - so I'm not completely familiar with what you're mentioning.

    On a completely separate note, for some reason this post made me tear up a little bit. It could be for the hope that you always have ingrained in your writing, or the love for Walk Kowalski, or more likely, just my allergies; but either way, I thought this was a beautiful post. :)
  • Re: tearing up - you know I think I actually cried a bit while watching Gran Torino - surprising I know, but true - it's the last Dirty Harry film - and he tries to redeem himself through non-violence = brilliant.
  • Something funny is that earlier, my roommates and I were watching the most recent MAD MEN on On Demand, and as I fast forwarded through the commercials, the trailer for Invictus came on - and was onscreen for like 5 seconds in FFW. They all wanted to know what that was, having seen Freeman, Damon and Eastwood's name. So, I rewound to watch the trailer and afterwards they were all like, "meh". That also made me tear up, but not in the same way you're talking about.

    (And I loved Gran Torino, btw. I was very sad that it failed to garner any Oscar noms. Except for Best Song, I'm fine with that not being nominated - although having Clint sing that live on the awards show would have been awesome!)
  • garethhiggins75
    Thank you sir - that's very kind of you to say.
blog comments powered by Disqus